How Fear Affects Financial Decisions
I recently did an article on how fear holds us back from financial prosperity in particular how fear holds us back from tacking action. Yet, fear also is used in marketing. In marketing, fear is used to get people to take action by buying their (financial) product. The act of buying though is shifting responsibility and future action from the buyer to the seller. Thus, fear is still holding the person back from taking future action by transferring responsibility to the seller. The belief is that the financial expert can do a better job with your money than you can.
I am not saying that all financial products are sold by fear or are all financial products are bad. Yet, as consumers, we need to do a better job in investigating the products. It is o.k. to shift responsibility to a financial expert, yet do not shift your responsibility without doing your own due diligence.
For example,
• Variable Annuities – are typically sold out of fear of taxes and retirement risks. Variable annuities are sold as a tax shelter where the investment grows tax free until the money is withdrawn. Yet, there are better tax deferred vehicles like IRAs and 401(k)s that many people are not maxing out before investing in variable annuities. In addition, some variable annuities are sold in IRAs, thus losing the tax advantage which is normally a selling point of a variable annuity. In addition, variable annuities usually have high fees and commissions that reduced or eliminated any advantages. For more see the end of an article about Prudential Variable Annuity Complaints for a list of articles about variable annuities.
• Financial Advice – are trying to distinguish themselves from others by making other advice sound “stupid” or “old school”. The message is unless you want to fear being led astray by other “stupid” or “old school” financial advice; you need to their book or personal advice for new and hipper advice. Unfortunately, this scare tactic does two things. One, people buying into their advisor’s mutual funds at higher fees with no assurances that advisor’s future returns will beat the market. And, people are becoming more skeptical of financial advice because everywhere they turn, someone is giving them different advice by saying someone else is wrong. So who do you believe?
• Retirement – has a lot of fear of having enough to live on. We want to retire earlier and earlier while living longer and longer. Thus, we need a lot of advice on how much we need to save to live on. Yet, if we realize that retirement is relatively a new concept (in the last 50 years), we can see that many had to work in their “retirement years” before this (see Retirement Age). There is a lot of stigma on needing to retire early (to escape the workforce) that people feel like a failure if they did not save enough. And, many will try to retire even if they do not have enough. And, it is from this fear that people are trying to jump on the newest fad (home ownership, rental property, self-employment, etc.) hoping that this is the trick to be have a happy and secure retirement.
• Scarcity – is affected by the belief in a limited supply. Thus, people base their decision of getting it before it disappears. This can be seen with joining the band wagon of latest financial security boom (tech boom, oil stock boom, etc.). You need to buy in before it is too late. It is also seen with oil and gas prices. There are large variations of prices because people buy thinking that the supply will run out. Yet, after 40 years of hearing that oil running out, there are still new supplies being discovered every few weeks. Then why are prices so high? Fear and producers controlling supply (just like the diamond industry).
So what can we do? Remove the idea of scarcity and need. When we believe in scarcity, we hold onto what we have tighter and believe that we have no control. If we believe gas is a scarce resource, we will not let go of needing it. If we had just changed our driving habits for 1 month when gas hit $2, OPEC and oil companies would have been forced to drop their price. Yet, we said that we can not have enough gas and kept on driving as much as we always did. As a group, we did not jump on mass transit or drive slower (to save gas) to flex our muscle. We acknowledge the need and scarcity of gas and did nothing except complain and fearing higher prices. Thus, we just kept on buying gas hoping someone else would solve the problem. No wonder, gas prices went to $3, because it could.
Best advice on fear – Trust your instincts. If you are driven by fear of what may happen, take a step back and do research. If fear is driving the decision, then you are more likely to make a wrong decision. For example, one of the biggest investment mistakes is selling low (after a drop in market price) and buying high (joining the band wagon late) based on fear. So, do not make a rash decision based on what has just happened or what may happen. Do your research. If your research shows promising results and your fear has dissipated, then go ahead and buy (or sell). Yet, do not let fear drive the decision.
| Topic Menu | |
| Blog |
September 9th, 2006 at 8:07 am
That’s so true about fear being used to sell financial products. I went to seminar held by a financial advisor several years ago (just after the Nasdaq crash), who tried to intimidate everyone into signing on with him. He represented a large, reputable company (which should have presumably used more above board marketing techniques), but continued to remind the audience of the uncertainty in the markets, the mistakes we had made investing on our own, etc. I ran away from him as fast as possible.
September 11th, 2006 at 4:59 am
[”Best advice on fear – Trust your instincts.”]
__________
… “Use the Force, Luke”
Nonsense.
September 11th, 2006 at 5:25 am
I use to think the gut feel and things like that were kind of out there myself. Yet, there are just too many things that I have heard from close friends that have changed my mind. Recently, a friend had a few dreams where 444 came to him. This kinds of freaked him out because he normally does not remember his dreams. A couple days later after working a 15 hour day, he told his client that they should break for the night. His client said that he would come back a few hours later (in the middle of the night) to finish their work. My friend (who would normally say sure let’s do it) told him that it wasn’t worth it and to stay home with his family. The next morning he came into work and found the police there. In the building, two doors down from the office they were in, the cleaning lady was murdered at 4:45 according to the police.
Now you can say my friend made this up to prove in psychic nonsense. Yet, until we look at coincidences in your lives, we do not understand how our gut instinct can be a warning or a guide. So yes, “use the force” sounds out there. Yet, after this, I do not want to dismiss it either.
September 14th, 2006 at 11:39 am
[…] Carnival of Personal Finance with “How Fear Affects Financial Decisions” […]
October 5th, 2006 at 10:40 am
Carnivals - Carnival of Personal Finance hosted……
This week’s Carnival #65 of Personal Finance was hosted by NoCreditNeeded. It was a great carnival of information sharing with around 40 quality posts which made it through the final cut by NoCreditNeeded. Some of our favorite posts from this carniva….